Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The Pakistan Observer
  • Latest Stories
  • Pakistan
  • Business
    • Gold Prices
    • Silver Prices
    • Fuel Prices
    • Pakistan Stock Exchange
  • Forex
    • Open Market Rates
    • Inter Bank Rates
  • Lifestyle
    • Islamic & Regional Calendar
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Pakistan Observer
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Why Quackery Thrives in Pakistan: The Crisis of Trust

Opinion Desk by Opinion Desk
November 17, 2026
in Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
Why Quackery Thrives in Pakistan: The Crisis of Trust

Every few months, Pakistan’s medical fraternity goes through a familiar wave of outrage. A self-proclaimed naturist or uncertified practitioner appears on television or a viral podcast, making claims that contradict established medical science. Patients are told that high blood pressure is merely stomach gas or that biopsies cause cancer to spread. They may be told that common diagnoses are exaggerated or essential medicines are part of a corporate scam. In one particularly disturbing recent instance, people were advised to use black salt during an active heart attack instead of seeking emergency medical care.


Such claims are not simply another opinion. The real danger is when an unproven and potentially harmful remedy is offered instead of urgent treatment. During a heart attack, every minute matters and delaying treatment can have devastating consequences.


Yet focusing only on the individual charlatan misses a more uncomfortable truth. Quacks do not thrive simply because they are exceptionally convincing. They thrive because there is a vacuum, and our healthcare system has not always been able to fill it with something better.


Pakistan does not lack laws or regulatory bodies. PEMRA regulates broadcast media, DRAP has a mandate over therapeutic goods and their advertising, while PM&DC and provincial healthcare regulators have responsibilities within their respective jurisdictions. The problem is often enforcement, coordination and the speed with which action follows harmful claims.
Mainstream media can give an uncertified practitioner something difficult to take back once it has been granted: legitimacy. Presenting evidence-based medicine and pseudoscience as two equally valid sides of a debate is not balance. Science does not become a matter of opinion simply because both sides have been given equal airtime.


Digital platforms have made the problem even more complicated. YouTube, podcasts and social media have created enormous opportunities for health education, but they have also allowed anyone with a camera, a confident voice and an algorithm-friendly message to become a health authority in the eyes of millions. Sensational claims often travel much faster than cautious explanations. Health misinformation is increasingly recognized as a public-health challenge because it can influence how people understand disease, prevention and treatment.


But regulation alone does not explain why people listen. Scroll through the comments under almost any post related to healthcare and the pattern is striking: qualified doctors can face fierce criticism and distrust, while unqualified personalities are defended passionately. It is tempting to dismiss this as ignorance. I think that explanation is too easy. For many patients, distrust has been learned through experience.


Pakistan’s public health expenditure remains below 1 percent of GDP. In some busy outpatient departments, doctors may see dozens of patients during a single shift, leaving only a few minutes for each consultation. Within that brief encounter, the doctor is expected to assess the patient, review investigations, make a diagnosis, explain the condition and discuss treatment.


This is where the charlatan has a remarkable advantage. Unburdened by the volume of a public hospital and unconstrained by the uncertainty that comes with real medicine, the alternative practitioner can offer what the formal healthcare system often struggles to provide: time, attention, simple explanations and certainty.


The doctor says the condition needs long-term management. The charlatan promises a permanent cure. The doctor discusses risks and uncertainty. The charlatan offers a simple answer with confidence. Patients are not necessarily choosing pseudoscience over science. Sometimes they are choosing the person who appears to listen, understand and offer hope. Simply banning one practitioner is unlikely to solve the problem.


Regulators need to act consistently against dangerous medical advice from those presenting themselves as healthcare authorities without appropriate qualifications. Broadcast and digital platforms also need to distinguish genuine debate from false equivalence between evidence-based medicine and pseudoscience.


The medical profession also needs to reclaim the public conversation. Qualified doctors need to become more visible online and explain medical issues in language ordinary people understand. If we leave that space to influencers, we should not be surprised when they fill it.


But there is another responsibility that is less comfortable to discuss: we need to rebuild trust inside the healthcare system itself.


Patients do not always need a doctor to promise a cure. Often, they simply want someone who will listen, explain what is happening and take their concerns seriously. Hospitals that improve patient experience, reduce unnecessary barriers and communicate transparently do more than improve satisfaction. They make it harder for misinformation to find an audience.
Quackery is therefore not merely a problem of ignorance. It is also a problem of trust.


The next time a viral health personality makes an outrageous claim, our instinct will probably be to demand that the authorities ban them. Sometimes that may be necessary. But we should also ask a more difficult question: what is it about our healthcare system that makes their message so attractive in the first place?


Until we address that question, banning one quack will simply open the door for the next.


Dr Haseeb Khan is a professor of pathology based in Lahore. His interests include clinical lab management, medical education and improving healthcare systems.

We welcome your contributions to The Pakistan Observer, Submit your blogs, articles, press releases, news story pitches and news features.

Please send your submissions to our News Room or Editorial team.

News Room | Editorial Team
Share130Tweet81
Previous Post

We Preach Honesty but Practise Deception: The Moral Contradiction of Our Society

Next Post

The Graduate Skills Bill Has Two Payers

Opinion Desk

Opinion Desk

Next Post
The Graduate Skills Bill Has Two Payers

The Graduate Skills Bill Has Two Payers

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

CAD to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 17, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 17, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

AED to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 17, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 17, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

SAR to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 17, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 17, 2026
Interbank Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

Interbank Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 17, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates – 17 November 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 17, 2026
The Pakistan Observer

The Pakistan Observer brings the latest Pakistan news, breaking updates, business news, forex rates, lifestyle stories and expert opinion.

Useful Categories

  • Latest Stories
  • Business
  • Gold Prices
  • Fuel Prices
  • Forex
  • Opinion

Useful Links

  • About The Pakistan Observer
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contribution Guidelines

Contact Us!

info@pakobserver.com.pk

© 2026 The Pakistan Observer. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Latest Stories
  • Pakistan
  • Business
  • Forex
    • Open Market Rates
    • Inter Bank Rates
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • Prayer Timing

© 2026 The Pakistan Observer. All Rights Reserved.