Sunday, November 22, 2026
The Pakistan Observer
  • Latest Stories
  • Pakistan
  • Business
    • Gold Prices
    • Silver Prices
    • Fuel Prices
    • Pakistan Stock Exchange
  • Forex
    • Open Market Rates
    • Inter Bank Rates
  • Lifestyle
    • Islamic & Regional Calendar
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
The Pakistan Observer
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

When Merit Comes from the Desert: Let the MDCAT Result Speak | Sajjad Ahmed

Opinion Desk by Opinion Desk
October 7, 2026
in Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
1
When Merit Comes from the Desert: Let the MDCAT Result Speak | Sajjad Ahmed
ADVERTISEMENT

The recent MDCAT results in Sindh have opened an important conversation—not merely about an examination, but about merit, opportunity, and our attitude towards talent emerging from places that are often overlooked.

The Medical and Dental College Admission Test 2026, conducted through Sukkur IBA’s testing services, produced an unusual and striking merit pattern. Out of 33,336 candidates who appeared across Sindh, 16,507 were declared successful, giving an overall success rate of 49.5 per cent.

ADVERTISEMENT

The highest score was 179 out of 180. What attracted the greatest public attention, however, was the geographical distribution of the highest achievers. No candidate from Karachi appeared among the top 20, while five students from Tharparkar secured positions in that list. Twelve students from Tharparkar were also among the top 50.

Instead of celebrating this remarkable achievement, sections of the public discourse have immediately turned towards suspicion and allegations against the testing institution.

Questions about examination transparency are legitimate in any high-stakes test, and every credible testing organization should be prepared to answer them through evidence, documentation, audits, and an appropriate grievance mechanism.

But there is a fundamental difference between asking for verification and declaring a result questionable simply because it does not conform to our expectations.

The fact that Karachi produced no candidate in the top 20 cannot, by itself, establish irregularity. Nor can the presence of five students from Tharparkar prove anything beyond what the result itself demonstrates: those students performed exceptionally well in this particular examination.

Indeed, perhaps the more important question is why we find it difficult to accept excellence when it comes from a less privileged district.

Tharparkar is frequently discussed in Pakistan through the vocabulary of deprivation, drought, poverty, and lack of opportunity. Yet the MDCAT result has offered another image of the district: talented young people capable of competing at the highest level when given an equal examination platform.

Their success should not become a reason for suspicion. It should become a reason for investigation of a different kind—an investigation into how many talented children across rural Sindh remain undiscovered.

This is where Sukkur IBA deserves a fair assessment.

Sukkur IBA has developed a substantial institutional identity in testing, education, and merit-based selection. Its testing services have been entrusted with major public examinations in Sindh, and its official website has publicly posted the MDCAT 2026 answer keys, provisional results, and final-result announcements.

The institution should certainly welcome independent scrutiny. In fact, transparency strengthens rather than weakens an examination system.

If candidates or parents have concrete complaints, the appropriate response is to examine CCTV records, attendance records, OMR sheets, answer keys, scanning procedures, and other relevant evidence.

Such demands have already been raised publicly following the 2026 result, including calls for an independent review.

But scrutiny must remain scrutiny. It should not become a verdict before evidence is examined.

There is another misconception that deserves correction. A university’s credibility cannot be established simply by comparing one international ranking number with another. Different ranking organizations measure different things.

NED University, for example, has a long and distinguished engineering tradition and is currently ranked 1501+ in the Times Higher Education World University Rankings 2026, while its QS Asia 2026 ranking is 478.

Sukkur IBA’s current QS profile, meanwhile, lists it at 1501+ in the QS Sustainability Ranking 2026.

Therefore, the argument should not be that Sukkur IBA is “better than NED” because of a particular ranking. That would oversimplify the evidence.

NED is an established engineering university; Sukkur IBA has built its own reputation, particularly in business, technology, education, and testing. Their institutional missions and areas of strength are not identical.

The stronger argument is simpler: Sukkur IBA should be judged by evidence, not by geography.

If its MDCAT process has been conducted according to the approved procedures, then the results should be accepted unless credible evidence demonstrates otherwise.

If there are genuine procedural questions, they should be investigated transparently. Either way, the students themselves should not become collateral damage in an institutional controversy.

Most importantly, let us not make the mistake of believing that academic excellence belongs exclusively to metropolitan Pakistan.

A student from Karachi has every right to succeed. A student from Lahore, Hyderabad, or Islamabad has every right to succeed. But so does a student from Mithi, Nagarparkar, Islamkot, or any other remote corner of Sindh.

Merit has no postcode.

The extraordinary performance of Tharparkar’s students should therefore be treated not as an embarrassment to Karachi nor as proof of anyone’s superiority, but as a reminder that Pakistan’s intellectual potential is far wider than its major cities.

If the MDCAT result is challenged, let the evidence decide.

If the examination process is questioned, let an impartial review answer the questions.

But until credible evidence establishes otherwise, the achievement of students from Tharparkar deserves what every high-scoring candidate deserves: recognition, respect, and congratulations.

And Sukkur IBA deserves the same principle that it is being asked to apply to thousands of candidates—a fair assessment based on evidence.

We welcome your contributions to The Pakistan Observer, Submit your blogs, articles, press releases, news story pitches and news features.

Please send your submissions to our News Room or Editorial team.

News Room | Editorial Team
Share130Tweet81
Previous Post

Silver Prices Today in Pakistan – Latest Market Rates

Next Post

Pakistan’s IT Exports to UAE Surge 42% to $536 Million

Opinion Desk

Opinion Desk

Next Post
Pakistan’s IT Exports to UAE Surge 42% to $536 Million

Pakistan’s IT Exports to UAE Surge 42% to $536 Million

Comments 1

  1. Muhammad Yusuf says:
    2 months ago

    Great job

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Silver Prices in Pakistan – 28 June 2026
Business

Silver Rate Today in Pakistan – 22 November 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 22, 2026
Gold price continues to drop, cheaper by 438,000 rupees per tola
Business

Gold Rate in Pakistan Today – 22 November 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 22, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

SAR to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 22, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 22, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

AED to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 22, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 22, 2026
Open Market Exchange Rates Today in Pakistan – Latest PKR Rates
Forex

CAD to PKR Rate Today in Pakistan – November 22, 2026

by Mohsin Ali (Business Staff Reporter)
November 22, 2026
ADVERTISEMENT
The Pakistan Observer

The Pakistan Observer brings the latest Pakistan news, breaking updates, business news, forex rates, lifestyle stories and expert opinion.

Useful Categories

  • Latest Stories
  • Business
  • Gold Prices
  • Fuel Prices
  • Forex
  • Opinion

Useful Links

  • About
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contribution Guidelines

Contact Us!

info@pakobserver.com.pk

© 2026 The Pakistan Observer. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Latest Stories
  • Pakistan
  • Business
  • Forex
    • Open Market Rates
    • Inter Bank Rates
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • Prayer Timing

© 2026 The Pakistan Observer. All Rights Reserved.